Every garage faces the same question at the counter: do we recommend premium, mid-range, or private-label/value? The right answer changes by driver, vehicle, and risk. Here’s a practical view—no hype.
What “Private-Label” Means in Practice
Many UK wholesalers carry exclusive/value brands alongside global names. These labels often give you better unit margin and steady supply, especially in bread-and-butter sizes. Validate wet-grip ratings and warranty terms; many wholesalers promote exclusives as a core edge.
Where Premium Wins—And Why
Lease/fleet or warranty-sensitive jobs.
Performance and EV torque (where compound and construction matter).
High-mileage users who notice noise, wet grip, and wear.
Recognised manufacturers (Michelin, Goodyear, Bridgestone, Pirelli, Hankook, etc.) carry strong consumer trust and published performance data.
Where Private-Label Shines
Price-sensitive motorists who just need safe, legal, reliable.
Older vehicles near end-of-life.
Quick-turn jobs where stock and cost trump brand.
The Margin Equation You Should Run
Look at gross margin per job, not just discount percentage:
Sell price (incl. fitting & disposal)
Purchase cost
Time on ramp
Comeback risk (and who pays when it happens)
Run a 90-day test: split premium/mid/value recommendations by driver profile and monitor profit per hour.
Handling Objections at the Counter
Safety: reference label ratings and wet-grip class.
Noise & comfort: explain differences clearly.
Mileage: be honest about expected wear relative to price.
Warranty & Returns—Write It Down
Have a simple printout for tyre warranty scope, exclusions (impact, under-inflation), and process. If your wholesaler offers fast claim handling, lean on it—some advertise robust support to trade customers.
Positioning on Your Website
Create three simple blocks:
Premium: for performance, EV, warranty.
Mid-range: everyday balance.
Value/private-label: best price with safe, legal performance.
Add a “Good / Better / Best” explainer and a “Request a Quote” form that captures reg + mileage + driving style—it helps your team steer the recommendation quickly.
The Balanced Take
Private-label helps margin and availability. Premium protects reputation and demanding use-cases. Mid-range keeps most drivers happy. The best garages stock options and guide, not push one answer for everyone.
